Pumpkin Seeds by Tyler Downs

Release date April 9, 2026Series Standalone (for now)Format ARC Review
Tyler Downs is a relatively new face in the indie horror community, but the trajectory is already unmistakable. His debut collection, Fifteen Eyes, delivered on every promise of its eye-catching cover by containing sharp, memorable short fiction that announced a writer with real instincts. Now, having read an advance copy of his debut novel, Pumpkin Seeds, I can say with confidence: Downs is about to start running with the big dogs of horror, indie and traditional alike.
Pumpkin Seeds follows Ed, Wren, and Sam who are paranormal investigators operating out of Salem with a rather unusual complication: one of them is dead for 51 weeks of the year, one is essentially a ghost, and one is a teenager. For the final week of October, they band together to solve Salem’s supernatural crimes. This year’s case is the worst yet: a family dead, a small child missing, and the 31st bearing down on all of them like a freight train.
Ed and Sam anchor the story, and while the setup is technically “private investigators,” the dynamic reads far more like a boy and his reluctant father figure and I mean that as the highest possible compliment. It’s warmer, stranger, and more affecting than any buddy-cop pairing could have been.
What Downs does especially well is characters. Even the side characters carry main-character energy, each one of them fully realized, scene-stealing, and deeply deserving of their own spotlight. I’d love to see him follow the cozy mystery model: a series set in this Salem, each book pulling a side character forward. You’ll know exactly who I mean once you read it.
Fair warning: this book made me cry. Twice. It’s the kind of story that lands harder than you expect, sneaks past your defenses, and leaves a mark. In the best possible way.
I had to fight the urge to send Mr. Downs a midnight DM just to call him an asshole. I didn’t, cause he’s actually a pretty chill guy. The book, however, is not.
The verdict
5-Stars
Read Pumpkin Seeds now, so you can say you were there before Tyler Downs went mainstream. That day is coming, and probably sooner than he expects.








